The Second Star Hoops in Titanium *Updated*
Now featuring our updated clicker hoop. After hearing your feedback, we redesigned the closure to create a stronger, more secure click while keeping the same lightweight comfort you already love.
Meet The Second Star Hoops — inspired by the magic of never growing up ✨
Designed for everyday adventure, they’re crafted from solid titanium for 24/7 waterproof, sweatproof, lifeproof wear. Lightweight and hypoallergenic, they’re made to stay comfy through every park day, gym day, or lazy Sunday. The polished titanium gives that dreamy, silvery shine — like starlight that never fades.
- DETAILS
- Solid titanium (ASTM-F136 medical grade)
- 24K Gold PVD Titanium
- Waterproof + sweatproof
- Hypoallergenic & nickel free
- Independently third-party tested
- Clicker closure for easy, secure wear
Made in China at a BSCI and Sedex-certified facility. Independently audited for ethical labor and environmental standards
Free shipping on orders over $125
Complete the look:
I have both sizes of the Second Star Hoops (8mm & 10mm) from @shopsubtledust, and I’m officially converted.
The subtle nod to Peter Pan — second star to the right — instantly won my heart because I truly never want to grow up. But beyond the whimsy, the quality is what sealed it for me. These hoops are beautifully made, lightweight, and feel luxe without trying too hard.
I also have the most sensitive ears and react to almost every metal — and I can wear these with zero irritation. That alone is huge for me.
I’ve been a stud-only girl since the day my ears were pierced… and somehow these changed that. They’re timeless, effortless, and special in that quiet way that makes you reach for them every single day.
Thoughtful design, impeccable quality, and just the right amount of magic ✨
Absolutely love these earrings. They are so dainty, yet perfect with any outfit. I get complimented so often on these. Perfect for daily wear, dress it up or dress it down.
These mini hoops are so cute for any fit! Pair with Mickey ears or a baseball cap for park days or grocery runs. I especially love how the gold sparkles are totally giving Evangeline 🐸💛
I love how light weight these are!!! I am so picky about earrings but I have absolutely loved wearing these!
These hoops are so perfect for every day wear — my friend gifted them to me and i absolutely ADORE <3
Oh my goodness, where to begin! I got mine in silver and these are seriously thee most comfortable lightweight earrings I’ve ever worn! I’ve showered and slept with them in and haven’t felt the need to take them out. They are also so so cute and sparkly, I’ve gotten a bunch of compliments on them. I love these so much and I can’t wait for Subtle Dust to grow this collection 💕✨
Absolutely adore these earrings! They are so lightweight and add the perfect little sparkle to every outfit. They also don’t irritate my sensitive ears at all! Highly recommend.
absolutely ADORE these earrings and have worn them every day since their arrival. My one qualm is they do come unhooked easily - I make sure they are as secure as possible but sometimes when I pull a top on they click off, or the other day I woke up and one was off on my pillow. Could be user error but other than that i LOVEEEEE these earrings!
Hi Alexa thank you so much for taking the time to leave this thoughtful review I’m so happy to hear how much you love these hoops, but I’m so sorry about the clasp not feeling as secure as it should. That’s absolutely not the experience we want for you.
I’m sending you a replacement hoop ASAP ❤️ We’re also actively reviewing our clasps to ensure every pair is extra secure before shipping and I apologize that one slipped through the QC process. Thank you again for your honesty and for supporting our small brand — it means more than you know.
I've been a Subtle Dust customer for a couple years now. These earrings are one of many purchases. I've never been disappointed by any SD product, but I wanted to highlight the amazing customer service. Tressa is kind, communicative and understanding. I always felt good about a Subtle Dust purchase, but after her patience in helping me resolve a recent issue with my earrings, I can say confidently that it is 100% worth the money. Can't wait to wear these earrings all the time :)
Was so excited to get these as a gift, but the clicker closure wasn’t secure enough :( I wore them daily for a week, then at some point one day, an earring had unclicked and the charms fell off. The hoop stayed in my ear but so sad I already lost one set of the charms.
Thank you so much for sharing this, and I’m truly sorry your charms fell off — I know how disappointing that must have been. Our hoops are designed with a double-click closure for security, but if yours didn’t hold, that may indicate the closure wasn’t constructed perfectly — and that’s absolutely on us.
I’ll reach out to you personally so we can take a closer look together and make this right.
I love them so much! Such a beautiful style and so excited to wear these everyday. I have super sensitive ears so was so hopeful they would work for my ears. Unfortunately, one fell off and I lost the charms, I was able to find the hoop again happily.
Thank you so much for your sweet review I’m so sorry to hear one of the hoops fell off — our hoops use a clicker-style closure, so they do need to be pushed until you hear a full snap to make sure they’re fully locked in. Don't worry about being too rough with them, they're solid titanium so they won't break. Once they’re clicked all the way, they’re super secure! I’m really glad you were able to find the hoop again, but I'm sorry the charms were lost 😭
I’ve been wearing my subtle dust earrings every day since they’ve arrived. I only wear earrings that I can wear 24/7 and these fit the bill. They’re comfy and non-irritating on top of being super cute. The delicate star charms are so adorable and perfect for everyday wear.
As a sensitive ear girlie these earrings are a game changer. I immediately put them in and had no issues wearing them for hours!! If you are on the fence...buy them!! You won't regret it. I can't wait to see what Subtle Dust jewelry comes next!
I have the 8mm titanium and I forget I’m wearing them. They’re so lightweight and comfortable and I have gotten so many compliments on them! I have sensitive ears that will start to get itchy after awhile with most earrings, but these I can wear all day with no issues. I’m obsessed with them. I’ve been a huge fan of Tressa and her brand for years and have purchased many of her products and when I saw jewelry was coming I was SO excited as a huge jewelry lover. I can’t wait to see what comes next for subtle dust jewelry!
I had completely given up on wearing earrings for about a year now. My ears are super sensitive and everything irritated them. I ordered these earrings and wow! My ears have not had any reaction to them at all. They are super lightweight and you forget you are even wearing them, yet they are super sturdy at the same time. I cannot believe I finally found the perfect earrings with subtle dust!!!
Truly gorgeous. I want to get another pair in the silver! So pretty… i cant wait to wear these everywhere
FAQ
Q: Will you restock sold out items?
A: Sometimes! Bestsellers do return, but not always. Sign up for restock alerts or keep an eye on our Instagram for updates.
Q: When will my order ship?
A: Orders typically ship within 2-3 business days from our studio. You’ll get a tracking email as soon as it’s on the way!
Q: How do the Oversized Tees fit?
A: Our oversized tees are intentionally roomy — we recommend ordering your true to size for that chill, slouchy vibe.
Q: Do you print on blanks like Gildan or Comfort Colors?
A: Nope — everything you see on our site is made by us, for us. We design our own custom fits and have our garments ethically produced from the ground up. That means no blanks, no shortcuts — just pieces that are quality, intentional, and totally unique to Subtle Dust.
Shipping
Fast shipping
Orders ship from our studio within 3 business days — often sooner! We don’t typically ship on Saturdays or Sundays, but we’ll get your order out as quickly as we can. <3
Order tracking
All orders (except sticker-only orders) come with tracking and insurance up to $100. You’ll get a tracking email as soon as your order ships so you can follow it along the way.
Reach out
Have a question we didn’t cover? Reach out anytime — we’re happy to help! You can email us at hello@subtledust.com or use the contact form and we’ll get back to you soon.
About us
🌿 OUR PROCESS
We design our own silhouettes and work closely with trusted, ethical production partners to bring them to life. Every piece starts with us — no blanks, no shortcuts.
✨ OUR VIBE
Soft, nostalgic, and made to last. Subtle Dust pieces are meant to feel like an old favorite from the start — cozy, lived-in, and easy to love.
💌 OUR MISSION
We make pieces that feel like your favorite day at the parks — just subtle enough to wear anywhere, and special enough to still feel the magic.